Oh the insanity continues over the move to ban kitchen appliances.
In a bold move that could reshape the appliance industry, California lawmakers have passed a bill requiring gas stoves to carry health warning labels—similar to those found on cigarette packs. If signed into law by Governor Gavin Newsom, this legislation would make it illegal to sell gas stoves without these labels by January 1, 2025, for online sales, and January 1, 2026, for in-store sales. The warnings are intended to alert consumers to the potential health risks associated with cooking on gas stoves, particularly regarding indoor air pollution.
The bill, AB 2513, introduced by Democratic Assemblywoman Gail Pellerin, represents a significant step in the ongoing debate about the environmental and health impacts of gas appliances. For years, environmental advocates like Climate Action Now have argued that gas stoves contribute to poor indoor air quality, releasing pollutants that exacerbate respiratory conditions such as asthma. In response, this legislation seeks to inform consumers by requiring gas stoves to bear adhesive labels that warn about the pollutants they emit and the potential health risks.
Supporters of the bill, including groups like the California Public Interest Research Group (CALPIRG), argue that these warnings are essential for public health. Jenn Engstrom, CALPIRG’s state director, emphasized that many families are unaware of the dangers gas stoves can pose. “Gas stoves create pollution in our homes,” Engstrom stated, “and this increases the risk of childhood asthma and other respiratory problems for our family. A lot of people just aren’t aware of this pollution, and we think that consumers deserve the truth.” For Engstrom and others, the warning labels would empower families to make informed decisions about their appliances and take necessary precautions, such as improving ventilation.
However, not everyone is on board. Critics, particularly within the gas stove industry, argue that the legislation unfairly targets gas appliances while downplaying the importance of proper ventilation—regardless of the type of stove used. Industry advocates assert that focusing solely on gas stoves distracts from the broader issue of indoor air quality. They claim the legislation reflects an overreach by government into consumers’ private lives and purchasing choices.
This isn’t the first time gas stoves have come under fire. In early 2023, U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission member Rich Trumka Jr. made headlines by suggesting that a ban on new gas stoves was under consideration. His comments ignited a media storm, with strong pushback from those who saw the potential ban as an attack on personal freedoms. Though Trumka later clarified that the agency wasn’t planning to confiscate gas stoves, the incident highlighted the growing national divide on the issue.
California’s proposed law would be the first of its kind, though other states like New York and Illinois have introduced similar bills. For now, California leads the charge, with the bill reaching the governor’s desk, awaiting his signature by the end of September.
If the law is enacted, the impact could be far-reaching. Not only would gas stoves sold in California require warning labels, but online retailers would also be required to post clear warnings about the pollutants gas stoves can release. These developments could shape the future of kitchen appliances, nudging consumers toward electric stoves or other alternatives.
